Madden Review: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5)
Madden is a busy, noisy biopic with wild performances from Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale. The characters never feel real, the wives get little to do, and the story will mainly please football fans.
Rating: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5)
Genre: Biographical Sports Drama
Language: English
Director: David O. Russell
Writers: David O. Russell and Cambron Clark
Cast: Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, John Mulaney, Shane Gillis, Joel Murray
Runtime: 1h 50m
Rated: R
Some films are hard to forget because they are great. Madden is hard to forget because it is so loud. David O. Russell’s biopic about football legend John Madden is set to arrive on Prime Video on 18 November, and it asks you to sit through nearly two hours of nonstop energy.
One critic compared it to being cornered at a party by someone wired on cocaine who will not stop talking. That sums up the mood.
The story begins in 1976. John Madden, played by Nicolas Cage, is the head coach of the Oakland Raiders. His playing days are long gone, and he has a great run of winning seasons, but a Super Bowl title keeps slipping away.
That changes the next year when the team beats the Minnesota Vikings in Super Bowl IX. His wife Virginia, played by Kathryn Hahn, hopes he will finally slow down and spend time with her and their sons, maybe even renew their wedding vows.
But Al Davis, played by Christian Bale, the team owner and his close friend, keeps reminding him that football is who he is. So John stays for two more seasons, until a bleeding ulcer forces him to retire.
Retirement does not suit him. He mutters football ideas to the family dog and cannot stay away from the game. He joins CBS Sports as a commentator, where his rambling, stream-of-thought style drives sportscaster Pat Summerall, played by Joel Murray, a bit crazy.
The film skips the rocky start between the two and jumps straight to the fun on-air partnership that made them famous. Another thread follows Trip Hawkins, played by John Mulaney, the founder of Electronic Arts. He wants to turn Madden’s knowledge into a video game. John is unsure at first, but once he hands over his giant binder of plays, the game becomes one of the best-selling of all time.
Cage is the main attraction. He wears a fat suit so large that he looks like a cartoon, and he plays Madden as a football genius who can also seem almost simple-minded. That gives the role a strange sweetness, and it is clear he loves his wife and sons, even if he is absent most of the time.
Bale goes just as big. He has a receding hairline, a tight scowl, and a thick Brooklyn accent, and Sienna Miller matches him as his wife Carol. The trouble is that both leads seem to be giving a performance, and you never forget it. That makes it hard to feel anything real for them.
The film also struggles with its drama. The fight between John’s love for his family and his love for the game never feels like it has high stakes. The friendship between John and Al is meant to be the heart of the story, but it is hard to care when they never feel like real people.
The two wives are shortchanged as well. Virginia’s divorce threats and Carol’s stroke and coma fizzle out before they build any weight. Shane Gillis appears as a neighbor who idolizes Madden, but he adds very little.
There are a few small positives. If you enjoy wild Nicolas Cage performances, you may get a kick out of this one. The film also moves at a quick pace, with period songs dropped in at every chance. It is a step up from Russell’s last film, Amsterdam, but it is still busy and abrasive without being very entertaining.
If you want something else to watch, our Madden OTT release date article has the key details. For a royal farewell, try our The Empress Season 3 review, and for a legal drama with a strong lead, read our Alicia’s Law review. If you prefer something slower and more serious, our Murder in Galicia review is also worth a look.
Madden has big swings but little heart. Unless you love football history or want to see Nicolas Cage bounce around in a pile of prosthetics, you can skip this one.
Madden arrives on Prime Video on 18 November.

